Added Maple Leafs alumni goalie Curtis Joseph: "It was unreal. It was vintage Mike Palmateer. We all played him as a road hockey goalie. Man, Tomas Holmstrom, he's not retired very long and he made a great move. It was great to see."
It might be the last save Palmateer ever makes. Maybe it should be.
"If he doesn't put his pads on again, that's a nice save for people to remember," Toronto alumni forward Gary Roberts said.
Palmateer doesn't play anymore anyway. The last time he suited up was at the 2014 Winter Classic alumni game at Comerica Park, where he made some similar crazy saves, just none on a penalty shot. Prior to that, he hadn't skated in 17 years.
"My legs are too bad, so I can't afford to," Palmateer said. "I don't want to hurt myself, but for an opportunity to come out and put the pads on one more time, you just have to do it."
Palmateer had to dig out his equipment bag in his basement, the same vintage equipment bag complete with the skates, pads, chest protector, glove, blocker and even jock strap that he wore when he played in the NHL. His mask for the alumni game was new, but even that was made to look like his old mask with the same face mold.
Palmateer said if Holmstrom went high with his shot and hit him in the mask, he likely would have been knocked out.
"We're all in awe of his equipment," Toronto alum Doug Gilmour said. "Let's be honest, you haven't seen that stuff in a long time."
Palmateer strapped it all on and skated for five minutes with the Maple Leafs alumni at Maple Leaf Gardens on Friday. His plan was to play only a few minutes Saturday, mainly because he had 60 family members in the crowd who wanted to see him play one more time.
He also planned to leave the game on his own accord, not because of an injury. That didn't work out.
"On the bright side, I had no excuse," Palmateer said. "I was already hurt. I couldn't stand up. The timing was great."
The save was better.
"Amazing," Detroit alumni goalie Chris Osgood said. "Unfathomable."