Cole Caufield had a goal and an assist, and Jordan Harris scored for the Canadiens (30-36-13), who have been eliminated from Stanley Cup Playoff contention. Montembeault made 31 saves.
“For us tonight, I didn’t feel like we had our fastball in the sense of execution,” Montreal coach Martin St. Louis said. “It’s props to the way they played. They made it hard on us to make plays in space.”
Harris gave the Canadiens a 1-0 lead at 17:58 of the first period. After Nick Suzuki’s shot in the left face-off circle was blocked by Islanders defenseman Ryan Pulock, Caufield set up Harris for a one-timer from inside the blue line.
Engvall tied it 1-1 at 5:17 of the second period. Pelech fed him in the left circle, and he carried the puck to the high slot before scoring high to the glove side.
Caufield gave Montreal a 2-1 lead at 3:42 of the third period, snapping a shot through Varlamov’s five-hole from low in the left circle.
Cizikas tied it 2-2 at 6:30. After Pelech missed a shot from the low slot, Cizikas gathered the rebound off the boards behind the net and scored with a wraparound at the left post.
“I thought we came out flat,” Suzuki said. “We obviously know the position they’re in and we definitely could have came out with a little bit more intensity. But as the game went on, I thought we did better things but we kept shooting ourselves in the foot.”