Wyatt Johnston and Craig Smith scored for the Stars (40-19-9), who have lost two in a row after a five-game winning streak. Jake Oettinger allowed four goals on 10 shots before being replaced by Scott Wedgewood (eight saves) in the second period.
“The frustrating thing is we came out and got the first goal. You’d like to think that’s a good sign and you can build on that,” Dallas coach Pete DeBoer said. “Instead, we were really flat for a big portion of the rest of that period, for sure. Dug ourselves a hole, and unlike San Jose and some of the other places where we’ve found a way to dig ourselves out, we didn’t tonight. But if you’re going to play that game, you’re not going to be able to do that every night. We got what we deserved.”
Johnston gave the Stars a 1-0 lead 15 seconds into the first period on a shot from the slot after fighting through three defenders.
Erik Haula tied it 1-1 at 5:41. He intercepted a clearing pass from Stars forward Jamie Benn, drove to the front of the net and chipped a shot into the near corner.
“They are good players against us, too, but we need to be careful with the puck and make the right plays at the right time,” Stars defenseman Miro Heiskanen said. “We don’t want to turn over the puck in our own zone, but sometimes it happens. Try to avoid those and clean it up a little bit, play a little more simple.”
Smith put Dallas back ahead 2-1 at 12:04 on a shot from the goal line that deflected in off Allen.
Tierney tied it 2-2 at 17:14 when his centering pass deflected off Heiskanen’s stick past Oettinger.
“We got some bounces. I thought we played pretty good for the first 40, and then we defended well in the third,” Haula said. “The last three games, Carolina, Rangers, we didn’t get rewarded. We played pretty good and definitely could have won those games. Now, a good team effort and a nice two points for us.”
The Devils scored three times in the first 5:12 of the second period to take a 5-2 lead.
Dawson Mercer made it 3-2 at 1:31. He took a pass from Nico Hischier and spun to the side of the crease before shooting high on the blocker side of Oettinger.