Bryan Rust scored twice, and Tristan Jarry made 26 saves for the Penguins (8-7-0), who are 0-5-1 against the Devils since a 4-2 win on Feb. 13, 2022.
“We just weren’t very good,” Pittsburgh coach Mike Sullivan said. “I’m not going to rationalize an answer. We weren’t good enough.”
Bratt gave New Jersey a 3-2 lead on a 4-on-4 at 2:35 of the third period, scoring his eighth this season on a wrist shot from the left face-off circle.
Alexander Holtz made it 4-2 on a one-timer at the left post at 11:24 before Tyler Toffoli scored his ninth of the season 20 seconds later on a snap shot from the slot, extending it to 5-2 at 11:44.
Rust put Pittsburgh ahead 1-0 at 6:36 of the first period. After taking a stretch pass from Jake Guentzel through the neutral zone, he drove to the slot before shifting the puck to his backhand and lifting it over Vanecek’s blocker.
Lazar scored short-handed to tie it 1-1 at 13:34. Haula stole the puck from Rickard Rakell for a 2-on-1, passing to Lazar for a wrist shot that beat Jarry five-hole from the right circle.
“These past few games, you get down and you kind of get deflated,” Lazar said. “You try to claw back. We just didn't have it. Tonight was completely different. I thought guys did a great job, skating through the neutral zone, managing the puck, making the Penguins work 200 feet to get a look.
“As the game went on, we just kind of settled in. You could tell guys are having fun again.”