Panarin, with two goals and three assists, had three or more points for the fourth consecutive home game, tying Andy Bathgate (Nov. 8-19, 1961) for longest such streak by a Rangers player.
Panarin previously had five points in a game on Dec. 8, 2017, when he had five assists for the Columbus Blue Jackets in a 5-3 win against the New Jersey Devils.
WATCH: [All Islanders vs. Rangers highlights]
He is third in the League with 67 points (26 goals, 41 assists) and first among forwards with a plus-23 rating.
"Every now and then he one-ups himself, and he did that again tonight," Rangers coach David Quinn said. "We talked about it when we signed him over the summer, everybody stands a little bit taller, they put their chests out a little further and they have a little more swagger, but I think he's given us a lot more than that."