Ottawa thought it had scored 33 seconds before Wahlstrom’s goal when Erik Brannstrom’s wrist shot went top right on Varlamov from the top of the slot at 5:49, but the Islanders challenged for offside and the goal was overturned after video review.
Barzal extended it to 3-1 at 9:51 on the power play, beating Forsberg blocker side with a wrist shot from the top of the slot. Lee made it 4-1 six seconds later at 9:57 with a wrist shot short side on a 2-on-2 rush.
“When they scored the 3-1 goal, it felt like we got behind, obviously,” Forsberg said. “And then I let in the fourth one there. I should’ve had that one. It’s uphill from there. I’ve got to find more consistency and get a few saves there. The team battled back hard. We had a [bad] bounce in the third. We’ve just got to keep working.”
Stutzle cut it to 4-2 at 10:56 after scoring in front of the net on a centering pass from Joseph before Batherson made it 4-3 at 11:43 when he took a cross-slot pass from Stutzle and beat Varlamov over the blocker.
“I was 100 percent confident we were going to win that game,” Stutzle said. “There was never a doubt in my mind. Even when they scored [to make it] 5-3, I thought we were going to win, for sure. We had some good looks. Give credit to their goalie, he made some huge saves, especially during the 6-on-5.”
Dobson’s slap shot from the point redirected off Senators forward Vladimir Tarasenko and in off Simon Holmstrom at 5:18 of the third period for the 5-3 final.
“It happens with guys going down, but two [defensemen] right away was pretty significant,” Lee said. “So, a huge, gutsy effort from those four back there, and we tried to do our best and talked as much as we could all night.”
NOTES: Lambert did not have updates on Pelech or Aho. … Barzal and Lee’s goals six seconds apart tied the second-fastest two goals in franchise history; New York’s fastest pair of goals came just three seconds apart on Nov. 30, 2016, against the Pittsburgh Penguins -- with the second scored into an empty net. … The Islanders and Senators combined for four goals in 1:52 -- the fastest four combined goals by two teams since Nov. 17, 2022, when the Montreal Canadiens (two) and Columbus Blue Jackets (two) did so in 1:50.