Barclay Goodrow scored twice against his former team, and Igor Shesterkin made 25 saves for the Rangers (20-8-4), who had lost four of their past five games. Mika Zibanejad scored the deciding goal in the third round of the shootout.
"I had a tough time napping today, I was pretty excited," Goodrow said. "But when the puck drops you are able to put all the other things aside and just focus on the game. I think you could see by my reactions after the goals I was pretty excited. It was a great game and I'm happy for the effort the guys put out tonight."
Goodrow, who helped Tampa Bay win the Stanley Cup the past two seasons before being acquired by New York in a trade for a seventh-round pick in the 2022 NHL Draft on July 17, received his championship ring before the game in front of many of his former teammates.
"It's bittersweet, I'll be honest, all these players … when you win a Cup … have a special place in your heart," Lightning coach Jon Cooper said. "But 'Goody' especially. He came here without a lot of fanfare and I think the trade (with the San Jose Sharks prior to the 2020 NHL Trade Deadline) was criticized by many people, and all he did was come in here and help lead us to two Stanley Cups. There's not too many players I've coached, not just in the NHL, in my career, that have the heart and gamesmanship that kid has."