Matthews had a chance to tie it at 6:04, but Shesterkin kept the Rangers up 2-1 with a stretching right toe save.
The Rangers killed off a two-minute minor penalty to Jacob Trouba for tripping at 12:25 with the score 2-1.
“The [guys] are going to be disappointed because we didn’t score,” Maple Leafs coach Craig Berube said. “Now there were some good looks on the power play tonight but the one in the third period, we didn’t execute very well on that one with our entries and we turned it over a couple times. When the game is on the line right there with an opportunity to tie it up, we’ve got to have more urgency.”
Later, at 16:24, Shesterkin made a glove save on Nylander, who shot from the left face-off dot to preserve the one-goal lead.
“I don’t know which one stood out most, there were so many of them I lose count,” Smith said. “I feel like he’s had a whole season of highlight reel already through four or five games this year. It’s pretty impressive what he’s able to do but I think we can probably do a better job of helping him out and not giving up all those chances.”
Kreider shot into an empty net at 19:00 to make it 3-1, and Panarin scored into an empty net at 19:46 for the 4-1 final. Panarin has six goals and six assists during his point streak.
NOTES: In Shesterkin's three wins this season, he has allowed a total of two goals. ... New York has scored at least four goals in each of its first five games. ... This is the fourth time in Rangers history (2008-09, 1997-98, 1983-84) that they have opened a season with a five-game point streak. ... Zibanejad's assist on Kreider's goal in the second period was his 300th with the Rangers, making him the 13th player to reach that mark. ... Toronto defenseman Chris Tanev left at 18:17 of the second period after blocking a one-timer from Zibanejad off the right knee. He returned for the third period but played only four shifts for 2:17… Matthews had a game-high nine shots on goal.