The winner was decided by fans voting on Twitter. Subban got 31 percent of the vote, narrowly defeating Brent Burns of the San Jose Sharks, who had 26 percent.
Subban came out for his second attempt in a Jagr No. 68 Florida Panthers jersey and a flowing mullet. After scoring on goalie Pekka Rinne, Subban added the familiar Jagr salute.
"He had no idea," Subban said. "I wasn't going to tell him. It had to be a surprise."
Other players were impressed.
"Black pants, the helmet," Evgeni Malkin of the Pittsburgh Penguins said. "I don't know where he found it, but it was really funny."
Jagr appreciated the gesture, as he does the loyal fans who sometimes show up at an arena dressed in all the jerseys he wore during his 22-season NHL career.
"You don't have to be the best in the world at something, you just have to be different," Jagr said. "And he is kind of different, and people love it. He's different the right way, the good way. ... It's good for the fans, they were loving that. All-Star is all about the fans and I'm glad he came. I'm very happy he did it."
Burns -- and his 4-year-old son Jagger -- were other favorites among those in the arena.
On Burns' first attempt, he was joined by Jagger, and Sharks teammate Joe Pavelski and his son Nathan. As former teammates Cory Schneider and Roberto Luongo staged a mock argument in the net to leave it empty, Jagger got the puck from Nathan and scored.
"He and Nate worked on the drop pass [this morning]," Burns said. "But you get two kids under 5, you never really know what's going to happen. So it was good to see it go off."
Jagger then did a celebratory dance and fist-bumped all of the all-stars as he skated by in his Lil Burns No. 88 jersey.
"That wasn't part of the routine," Burns said, laughing. "I told him ... ' Once you score, we're going to get a nice picture.' That went out the window. He was all over the map. ... He was pretty jacked."
Burns' second attempt started with pictures of him as a young player -- without facial hair -- along with the "Star Wars" theme. The arena lights came up, and Burns was wearing a Chewbacca mask as he went in to score on Schneider.
Any other year, it probably would have been more than enough to win. But Burns wasn't concerned about that.
"I got all the goodness out of just having it go through like that," Burns said, "and I'm pretty excited to see what he's saying now."
Each skater -- Brandon Saad of the Columbus Blue Jackets; James Neal of the Nashville Predators; Evgeny Kuznetsov of the Washington Capitals; Matt Duchene of the Colorado Avalanche; Subban and Burns -- was given two attempts.
Among the highlights were country music fan Duchene throwing a cowboy hat into the stands; Rinne using a guitar given to him by singer Dierks Bentley as a goalie stick; Neal using a puck hidden in his glove to score on Schneider; and Neal passing to Bentley, who scored on his shot.
Shooters were allowed to start from anywhere in the neutral zone and could use the entire offensive zone, including behind the net (regular-season shootout rules did not apply).
Subban kept the puck in the air on his first attempt, tapping it off his blade before heel-kicking the puck in the air before a spinning shot.
He then won the contest at his first All-Star Weekend.
"It's a tribute to the great player that he is, the career that he's had so far in the NHL, and the player that he's going to go down as when he's finished playing, and that's as one of the best players to ever play in the NHL," Subban said of Jagr. "He was one of my favorite players growing up, and it's a sign of respect.
"For me, it's a huge honor. For that five minutes, I was Jaromir Jagr, so it was pretty cool.
