The Penguins got contributions from throughout their lineup, including one from rookie center Sam Lafferty, who was called up Saturday, that tied the game at 1-1 with 8:14 left in the first period, 1:08 after Lars Eller gave the Capitals a 1-0 lead. A deflection goal from Patric Hornqvist gave Pittsburgh a 2-1 lead and all the momentum with 7:20 left in the first.
The Penguins were the better team through the second period with Simon's goal increasing their lead to 3-1 before the Capitals pushed back hard in the third. Forward Tom Wilson was credited with a career-high 13 hits, including nine of the Capitals' 22 in the third period.
"I think we got fed up a bit," Wilson said. "We need to come out a little bit stronger, but these are the games where you kind of come together and you learn from it. A couple breaks here and there don't go our way and it just seemed a bit of a frustrating game. We did our best to try and turn the tide and it was just little bit late."
After Kuznetsov cut to the net to lift a backhand past goalie Matt Murry and pull the Capitals within 3-2 at 6:00 of the third period, the Capitals had multiple chances to tie it. But Murray came up big, making 11 of his 29 saves in the third, including a left arm stop on Ovechkin from the right side with 6:18 remaining to keep it 3-2.
"It was just kind of a loose puck," Murray said. "I think it just was a shot on net, it hit somebody and went to the left and I guess it was Ovi who picked it up and he made a nice move. He kind of held on to it instead of just shooting it. I just tried to get over there as fast as I could."
After the Penguins got a goal from their third line, with Brandon Tanev scoring from the slot with 2:33 left, to make it 4-2, Eller responded 15 seconds later to pull the Capitals back within one, but they were not able to get the tying goal past Murray.