The Penguins have won three Stanley Cup titles (2009, 2016, 2017) since centers Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin became teammates in the 2006-07 season. They showed their mettle again Thursday against the up-and-coming Maple Leafs.
The majority of the pregame hype swirled around Toronto, which entered with a five-game winning streak. Center Auston Matthews came in leading the NHL with 16 points (10 goals, six assists) and had seven consecutive multipoint games to start the season. Only Mario Lemieux and forward Kevin Stevens (Penguins, 1992-93), Mike Bossy (Islanders, 1984-85) and Wayne Gretzky (Edmonton Oilers, 1983-84) also had streaks of at least that long.
Matthews' hot start mirrored that of the Maple Leafs, who had scored an NHL-high 33 goals in starting the season 6-1-0. Local talk shows were dominated by callers suggesting Matthews was the best player in the game.
Pittsburgh thought otherwise. Its championship pedigree overcame Toronto's talent and young legs, which came as no surprise to Maple Leafs coach Mike Babcock.
"I thought their team played good," Babcock said after Toronto was shut out for the first time this season. "I didn't think there was tons of room out there tonight. I thought they played fast, they played with good structure. It's not often you see our team get no goals. I just thought they did a good job.
"They're a more veteran, polished, playoff team than we are. It showed."
Babcock, holding the final line change at home, started the game with Matthews going head-to-head against Crosby. He pulled the plug on that plan after Matthews was relatively ineffective in the first period.
"It seems like they were just calm, cool, collected out there," Matthews said. "They didn't run around, they just played smart and didn't force anything and made plays. It seemed like they had us running around quite a bit."
Call it veteran savvy. Crosby is 31; Malkin is 32. Each feels he has plenty left in the tank despite critics claiming that the window of opportunity is closing on the aging Penguins.
"We certainly don't feel within our organization," Pittsburgh coach Mike Sullivan said. "We believe in this group. This is as good a core group of players as I've been around. They can still play. And they know how to win.
"You get everybody's best every night. You get that burden of responsibility every night when you've accomplished what this group has accomplished. That's a credit to them and the reputation they've earned."