Tennis legend John McEnroe, Lundqvist's close friend, gifted him an electric guitar from Hagstrom Guitars in Sweden, hand-painted with the former goalie's image and number by artist David Gunnarsson, who used to paint Lundqvist's masks.
Rangers head equipment manager Acacio Marques gave Lundqvist a case that includes 74 pucks, one from each of his NHL shutouts. Lundqvist, hugging Marques, wiped tears from his eyes.
New York alternate captains Artemi Panarin, Chris Kreider, Mika Zibanejad, Jacob Trouba, Ryan Strome and Barclay Goodrow presented him with three special bottles of wine from Vineyard 36 in a case autographed by members of the current team.
"It just honestly [stinks] that we couldn't end the night on a better note," Zibanejad said after the game, "especially with the way it started, the whole ceremony, seeing him, seeing his family and just listening to that crowd really. It was a night I'll never forget. I'm grateful I got to be a part of it. He deserves it all. I couldn't be happier for him."
Messier, Graves, Leetch and Richter unveiled a custom Louis Vuitton travel trunk with Lundqvist's number.
"I think in the history of the Rangers I don't think you'll ever find someone else who is so New York in every way, in the community, in the net, his compete, his hunger, his dress, everything," Graves said earlier. "When you talk about an organization that's been around close to 100 years and has a representation and continues to have a representation, certainly it doesn't get any better than the last 15 years with Hank."
Former goalie Kevin Weekes, Lundqvist's teammate from 2005-07, may have summed up the impact the honoree made in New York at the end of his remarks during the ceremony.
"All the greats play New York, all the greats play the Garden, but very few of them have played and dominated here the way in which you have," Weekes said. "Next stop, the Hockey Hall of Fame."