A few days after she missed Fleury, her brother, Matthew, got dressed up in the same outfit, mask and hairdo, and rang her doorbell pretending to be the goalie.
"It was hilarious. He studied the video to get it all right and even tried to copy Fleury's handwriting on the bag," she said. " Unfortunately for my brother, he doesn't have the physique of a professional athlete, so I figured out it was him right away."
McDonald moved to Las Vegas from Santa Fe, New Mexico in 2013. She was a Pittsburgh Penguins fan growing up thanks to her uncle but when the Golden Knights came into the League with Fleury in goal, she had a new allegiance. During their inaugural season when Vegas won the Western Conference title, McDonald attended all but two home playoff games.
So missing in person Fleury was extra tough.
"I felt mostly shock. And sadness that I missed him," she said. "Even living in Las Vegas, no one expected him to show up at my door."
She said she also won a contest where the prize was a Jake Guentzel Penguins jersey but it has not been delivered yet.
"No pressure, Jake!" she joked.