A goalie known for withholding his emotions, it was time for Binnington to finally let them bust out for the world to see.
"When the buzzer [sounded], I just grabbed anyone I could," he said. "It's just an amazing group of guys. Just a great feeling. When you believe in yourself, it doesn't matter how many others don't.
"It wasn't always easy. There were down times. I put myself in tough spots. The bigger the challenge, the greater the response. I just tried to adjust to the challenge every day and be the goalie I thought I could be and take advantage of my talent."
Through it all, his mind drifted to his minor hockey days and the role his father, John, played.
"I thought about how hard my dad worked to take me to hockey rinks as a kid. You can't take advantage of that," Binnington said. "You have to appreciate that. I so much appreciate what people like my dad and Coach Mike did for me."
Coach Mike is Mike Vallescuro, the man who switched Binnington from forward to goalie when he was 8 years old.
Binnington was trying out for the Vaughan Rangers of the Greater Toronto Hockey League at the time. The first shot he faced hit him right in the head, but he didn't flinch. That's when Vallescuro knew Binnington found a home in the crease.
Seventeen years later, Vallescuro wiped tears from his eyes at his Toronto-area home Wednesday while watching Binnington lift the Cup. After having a front-row seat for the start of Binnington's goaltending journey, he was witnessing the culmination.
"I just can't believe it from where he's come from," Vallescuro said in a phone interview. "I mean, I just remember him as a kid. I just remember him smiling, always smiling as a kid. All the hockey games we went to, the tournaments we went to. And now he's a grown man and hoisting the Stanley Cup.
"Jordan believed in himself. It's all him. He believed he was in the right situation, right team, right coach, and he took advantage. It's all about winning with Jordan. He doesn't care how he gets there. And now he's on the top of the world."