Now, finally, the Blues get their rematch. They play the Bruins in the Stanley Cup Final starting with Game 1 at Boston on Monday (8 p.m. ET; NBC, CBC, SN, TVAS).
"We owe Boston one," said Bob Plager, a defenseman for the Blues from 1967-68, when they entered the NHL, to 1977-78. "They beat us once before."
Ah, but Boston has defeated St. Louis even more than that. The storyline goes much deeper.
The Bruins, the Boston Celtics of the NBA, the Boston Red Sox of MLB and the New England Patriots of the NFL each have won a championship against a St. Louis team. No other city has won a championship in each of the four major sports leagues against the same city.
Boston teams have gone 7-3 against St. Louis teams in championship matchups, including 3-0 in the past two decades.
Overall, Boston teams lead St. Louis teams in championships in the four major sports leagues 39-13, including 12-3 in the past two decades.
RELATED: [Complete Bruins vs. Blues coverage | 1970 Cup Final was more than iconic Orr goal]
These are two of the great sports towns in America, similar in passion and pride. But look at what one has endured and the other has enjoyed:
Baseball?
St. Louis has 11 World Series titles, the Cardinals winning each. Boston has won 10 -- the Red Sox nine, the Boston Braves one.
In 1946, the Red Sox made the World Series for the first time since 1918 and lost to the Cardinals in seven games. When they finally made it back again in 1967, they lost to the Cardinals in seven games again.
The Curse of the Bambino, hovering over the Red Sox for selling Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees, lasted for 86 years in Boston.
But it was broken against …
St. Louis. The Red Sox swept the Cardinals in the 2004 World Series. They have won three more titles since, including the 2013 World Series against the Cardinals and the last World Series. The Cardinals have won two, in 2006 and 2011.