New York trailed 2-0 after the first period on goals by Johnson on a one-timer off a pass from Kucherov at 7:52, and Miller on the power play at 14:57 off Kucherov's deflected shot. It was Johnson's 300th NHL point.
"Listen, they're the best team in the League, they've got the best record, they're going to look good, but we made them look especially good because we just stood still," Quinn said of the first period. "We didn't close on anyone defensively. We didn't forecheck. We played in awe, I felt like."
Zibanejad cut the Lightning lead to 2-1 by scoring on a backhanded one-timer from the left circle 56 seconds into the second period.
"Our whole mentality changed it looked like," Quinn said. "It felt like on the bench a bubble burst and we kind of thought, 'OK, we're OK.' "
Girardi ended a 21-game goal drought to make it 3-1 at 2:53 of the second when he scored from the left circle off a cross-slot saucer pass from Steven Stamkos.