Marner cut it to 3-1 at 18:31 during the same power play. He gathered the puck in front of Bobrovsky following a face-off, got the goalie to commit low and lifted the puck over him from the right side.
After Toronto forward William Nylander got a double minor for high-sticking Florida defenseman Nate Schmidt at 13:20 of the third period, Verhaeghe made it 4-1 on the ensuing power play, putting a wrist shot over the right shoulder of Stolarz from the left circle at 14:27.
Bennett scored into an empty net at 18:32 for the 5-1 final.
“We talked before the game and knew 5-on-5 would be tight, but special teams were the difference,” Toronto coach Craig Berube said. “We gave up two power-play goals to them and a shorty. That was the difference in the game. … We have to be sharper, some of the penalties we did not need to take. We were trying to come back and took six minutes of penalties in the third. That makes it difficult.”
Florida was without center Anton Lundell, who needed stitches after taking a puck to the face during a 4-1 loss to the Washington Capitals on Monday. He had been a game-time decision.
“He was a little sore, and they put the big bubble [mask] and he just didn’t feel right,” Maurice said following the game. “I would think that he plays in the next game because he was very close to playing in this one. But he will have to play better.”
NOTES: Toronto forward Bobby McMann left the game with a lower-body injury at 15:54 of the second period. Berube said he is day to day. … Maple Leafs defenseman Oliver Ekman-Larsson and forward Steven Lorentz also faced the Panthers for the first time since winning the Cup last season; they and Stolarz received their championship rings in a private ceremony at Florida’s training facility earlier in the day. The three were honored with individual highlight videos during the first period. … Marner has nine points (five goals, four assists) in a five-game point streak. … With his 17th goal of the season, Reinhart moved into the NHL goals lead ahead of Edmonton Oilers forward Leon Draisaitl. He also scored his League-leading fourth short-handed goal.