Kevin Stenlund scored on a wrist shot from the right circle to give Utah a 4-2 lead at 8:38.
Miller got the Rangers within 4-3 at 9:18 when his dump-in went off the endboards and ricocheted into the net with Ingram behind the net waiting to play the puck.
Hayton gave Utah a 1-0 lead at 3:43 of the first period converting from in close near the left circle on a cross-ice pass from Nick Schmaltz. Hayton has three goals in three games this season after he had three goals while being limited to 33 games last season.
"I think last year was tough for me, missing a lot of time at the same time, you're watching a lot of games and learning a lot of stuff, so you just got a different perspective," Hayton said. "So I think I took some out into the offseason and also to start this season and some of it has paid off."
Panarin tied it 1-1 at 8:38 of the first period with a wrist shot in the slot off a drop pass from Alexis Lafreniere.
Jack McBain made it 2-1 at 1:48 of the second, stuffing in a rebound at the side of the net.
Panarin scored on a wrist shot from the left circle to tie the game 2-2 at 3:51 of the second with a power-play goal.
Utah has scored 16 goals in its first three games.
"We have a team with talent, but for us, the battle is to get inside, to get in dirty areas, get those greasy goals, those tipped rebounds, screens, those kind of things," Utah coach Andre Tourigny said. "And that opened up the next play. So I think we're, we're a threat at passing the puck, but we're a bigger threat right now going into net and getting those in-tight goals."
NOTES: Guenther and Hayton, who have each scored in each of Utah's first three games, became the fifth and sixth players in the NHL's modern era (since 1943-44) with at least one goal in each of a franchise's first three games (James Neal, Vegas Golden Knights, four games, 2017-18; Billy Harris, New York Islanders, three games, 1972-73; Kent Douglas, Oakland Seals, three games, 1967-68; Larry Keenan, St. Louis Blues, three games, 1967-68). … Utah's 16 goals through its first three games are the third-most by a franchise in NHL history behind the Toronto Arenas (27 in 1917-18) and the Montreal Canadiens (23 in 1917-18). … Lafreniere, who was playing in his 300th NHL game, had an assist and two shots on goal in 23:41 of ice time.