Rinne also didn't think anyone would touch his run of 13 shots without a goal, which came against the Metropolitan Division.
"Once Marc-Andre started getting up there, 10, 11, I was like, oh, boy," Rinne said. "That was pretty impressive. That was awesome."
New York Rangers goalie Henrik Lundqvist (5) finished third, followed by Winnipeg Jets goalie Connor Hellebuyck (3) and the Lightning's Andrei Vasilevskiy (3).
During the first round, Fleury denied Lightning forward Brayden Point with a glove save that sent him tumbling through the crease.
"That was fun," Fleury said. "He was like a crowd favorite, so it was nice to calm everybody down a little bit. That was nice."
The goaltenders allowed 11 goals on 62 shots.
"The event was good," Rinne said. "I thought it was good to get the goalies involved. In the past, I feel like we were just a cone out there, as a prop. In the past, we had those funny shootouts [Breakaway Challenge] and you were supposed to give up a goal. I liked it. It was a cool idea and it is well-executed. The fans love to see that kind of stuff; they love to see breakaways and they like to see individual skill. I thought that was a lot of fun."
All 36 skaters participated in the event, a shootout grouped by division when goalies competed to make the most consecutive saves. Each goalie faced one opposing division and a minimum of nine scoring attempts.
Each scoring attempt was officiated in accordance with NHL shootout rules. Players from each division shot in numerical order, lowest to highest, with the division captain shooting ninth. A goalie's round could not end with a save. If the captain's shot was saved, the goalie continued to face shooters until a goal was scored.
