Cullen, a member of the Anaheim Ducks, was in Toronto's historic Maple Leaf Gardens when he set up for a defensive zone faceoff. Standing opposite of him in the circle was future hockey Hall-of-Famer Mats Sundin. The puck dropped to the ice and Cullen lost the draw.
The Maple Leafs used the win to get a scoring chance. After Anaheim cleared the puck, Ducks head coach Pierre Page called Cullen immediately back to the bench.
"I remember my first shift. I lost (the faceoff) and they shot it on net and I got taken off the ice, so it was a short," Cullen laughed. "It was a short shift, but I remember it like it was yesterday. It's funny how fast it goes, but those moments are moments you never forget."
The game wasn't yesterday. It was Oct. 28, 1997, over 22 years ago. But it marked the beginning of a journey that has culminated in a 21-year NHL career, three Stanley Cup wins and, as of Tuesday night's game against Florida, the incredible milestone of 1,500 regular-season games played.
"It's a cool number," a 42-year-old Cullen said of reaching 1,500. "I think when I'm all done and have time to look back on it I'll be proud of it. It's not easy to play in the game. It's a young man's game; it's a fast game. To be able to play this long is an honor."
Cullen made stops in eight NHL cities in his career: Anaheim, Florida, Carolina (two stints), NY Rangers, Ottawa, Minnesota (two stints), Nashville and Pittsburgh (two stints). Two of those teams (Minnesota, Nashville) didn't exist on the night Cullen made his NHL debut.
Cullen's 1,500 games played are the second-most by an American-born player and 20th all-time in the NHL (Cullen will likely pass Steve Yzerman, 1,514 for 19th this season). He's played in 1,628 games total when accounting for playoffs, not to mention those three Stanley Cups (two with Pittsburgh, one with Carolina).
"The first time in the playoffs was pretty special, just getting there," Cullen recalled. "The Stanley Cup runs are for me what stands out the most. Those are the ultimate. To be able to go through those experiences, those are the things I'll remember the most."