"When I was walking in, there was somebody breathing fire and there were people on stilts everywhere," she said with a laugh. "It's just fabulous."
The fire breathers and stilt walkers were sideshow performers that were a part of this year's theme, "Under the Big Top," which featured a variety of entertainment that captured the mystique of a vintage circus from yesteryear.
The "Night of Assists" is the organization's new signature charity event, combining two past galas - Aces and Ice, which the team had been doing since 1986, and the Wine Tasting Gala - into one.
Proceeds from the event will benefit the Penguins Foundation's vast array of youth initiatives and special needs programs that benefit children throughout the greater Pittsburgh region.
"We took two events that we had in the past and we combined it into one major event," said Dave Soltesz, President of the Penguins Foundation. "Just to make it easier. Schedules are tight for folks, so we thought 'hey, let's have one big bash,' and that's what this is all about.
"It's like when you're a kid, you went to the circus and had all these great things going on. It's a special night. It's a special event."
Cain couldn't have agreed more.
"I've got to tell you, you guys have outdone yourselves here tonight," she said. "It's just phenomenal. The Foundation does such great work and to be here supporting that is so tremendous in our community. And to see our players, they're such outstanding citizens, we're so proud of our Pittsburgh Penguins."
For those who attended the VIP reception prior to the event, they walked down a hallway where they were given beverages from hands outstretched from behind a curtain on what was called the "Champagne Wall."
Vintage posters featuring the players as different attractions decorated the walls. A few examples included Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin as the Two-Headed Man, Matt Murray as the Elastic Man, Carl Hagelin as the Human Cannonball and Ryan Reaves as the Strongest Man Alive, and the boys got a kick out of them as they walked in and checked them out.
Once they entered the Lexus Club, patrons sipped their drinks as they watched acts that included a snake charmer and juggler and mingled with players, coaches, management and executives. Upon heading downstairs, they all walked onto an area floor that was completely transformed into a Grand Circus. It featured an open bar with signature cocktails themed to the event - named the Houdini, the Bearded Lady, the Acrobat and the Arnold Slick - as well as a wine tasting with over 30 global wines and food stations featuring carnival cuisine with a twist.
At center ice was a stage, where AT&T Sports Network personality Dan Potash - serving as the ringmaster - introduced the players, who joined him wearing black top hats with red and yellow feathers, white gloves and Penguins jerseys. They also had canes, which Evgeni Malkin used to playfully whack Potash as he walked onto the stage.
Malkin almost gave Potash another love tap after the master of ceremonies volunteered him and Phil Kessel to do a couple of tricks for the crowd with renowned local magician Lee Terbosic. This was right after Terbosic had done some tricks for the players in the locker room beforehand, where Malkin had everyone cracking up when he was told to write his name on a card and instead wrote "Fill" for "Phil."