Poile remained with Fletcher and the Flames for 10 seasons, eventually becoming assistant general manager, the whole time with Fletcher serving as his mentor, teaching him the ins and outs of what it took to be a successful GM in the top hockey league in the world.
In 1982, the Washington Capitals called and Poile landed his first gig as an NHL GM. Then, after a successful, 15-year run in the nation's capital, it was off to Nashville to build a franchise from the very beginning, just like Fletcher once did.
This time around, it was Poile picking up the phone looking for assistance. Ray Shero was on the other end of the line.
"I would hear David talk about Cliff a lot, and I know what a mentor is, but I never really knew what it meant until I had spent eight years with David," said Shero, who was Nashville's assistant general manager from the franchise's inception in 1998 until 2006. "David is my mentor, and if you're lucky enough to have that in your life like he is with Cliff, and me with him, to impact someone like that is amazing."
Now the general manager of the New Jersey Devils, Shero got his first GM job with Pittsburgh in May of 2006 and won a Stanley Cup with the team in 2009. When the Penguins came courting over 10 years ago, Shero felt he was ready to lead his own club, but another offer of the same title from a different franchise was already on the table. Once Pittsburgh called, Shero, after being unable to reach his wife to tell her the news, phoned his mentor.
"I called him, and I'm like, 'David, you're not going to believe this, I just got a call from [former Penguins CEO] Ken Sawyer and he offered me the job!' And David says, 'Congratulations, that's fantastic! What are you going to do?' And I said, 'What am I going to do? That's why I'm calling you, what should I do?'"
Highly skilled in the art of communication and dealing with people, Poile had the perfect response, although it didn't necessarily seem helpful in the moment.
"David's like, 'Listen, we've worked together for eight years and remember all the times I told you when you become a general manager, you're going to have to make that final decision?'" Shero recalled of the chat. "'Well, congratulations, you're going to be a general manager, so just let me know what you decide.' And then click. He hung up on me! And there went my lifeline.