So, Predators General Manager David Poile went to work. He asked each team - starting with the club who owned the first selection of the second round, No. 31 - if they would make a deal to allow Nashville to move up. At pick No. 38, Poile found his match.
The Arizona Coyotes agreed to a deal with the Preds that if the player Nashville wanted was still available at 38, they would make the trade. After sweating it out for the first seven picks of Round 2, Josi's name was still on the board.
Poile dealt two Nashville picks - Nos. 46 and 76 in that 2008 Draft - to the Coyotes for No. 38. Nothing is ever certain in the draft, but once the Preds selected Josi, optimism was plentiful at the table.
"You never know for sure, it's not an exact science, but I just remember having a really good gut feeling on this one," Kealty said of the pick to take Josi. "We knew what we saw all year, and again, nothing is for certain, but I just think that we all felt really strong and felt really good about this. And here we are all these years later and he's a Norris Trophy winner."
Kealty recalls getting back to Nashville for Development Camp with all of the top prospects in the organization in attendance, Josi included. On the first day of camp, there was a meeting to allow for introductions, camp expectations and other pertinent details for the prospects.
Still on the high of the Josi selection just days earlier, there is one more moment from that experience Kealty will never forget.
"We're having this introductory meeting with all of the kids, and David Poile comes in," Kealty said. "He just kind of sits down next and just whispers to me, 'So, which one's Josi?'"
It wasn't long before everyone in Nashville knew exactly which one was the kid from Switzerland. Now, Josi is not only the captain of the franchise, he's also the first of the Preds to bring home the Norris.
That was worth trading up for.
"I texted him last week when we found out he was going to win the award and just said, 'It's really been a pleasure to watch you develop from the kid that we drafted 12 years ago to now,'" Kealty said of his conversation with Josi. "I was really happy for him to win the award, because sometimes with these awards, you just never know which way it's going to go. There's a lot of different factors based on the voting and all those sorts of things, and from somebody that watches a lot of hockey for a living, there's absolutely no doubt in my mind who the top defenseman in the League was this year. From that standpoint, I was just very happy for him to be recognized.
"To look back on these sorts of things, it's been really neat to just watch the whole process over the years. You remember watching them as kids and all that development to where he is now. He's one of the top players in the world, and it's really a cool experience."