Buffalo did indeed have its fair share of chances throughout the game that just didn't materialize into goals. It began in the first period, when Johan Larsson backhanded the puck into the net but the goal was waved off because a whistle had been blown, and continued into the third period of a 1-1 tie and then into overtime.
Once the game got to a shootout, Sam Reinhart scored on a backhand for the Sabres while Kyle Okposo and Cal O'Reilly were stopped on their chances. The Red Wings only needed two shooters: Gustav Nyquist, who beat Lehner between the pads, and former Sabre Thomas Vanek, who scored with his patented "around the world" snap shot he'd used so many times in blue and gold.
"Every shooter for me right now is a tough shooter," Lehner said. "I'm not really in the zone in the shootouts, if you put it lightly. I've been practicing it every day and in the practice I'm stopping the puck and in the games I'm not. A point slipped away and it sucks, but again, four posts."
The Sabres best chances in overtime came from Ryan O'Reilly, who made his return to the lineup after a five-game absence due to an oblique injury. With the puck down low in the offensive zone, O'Reilly treated the Red Wings players like obstacles in one his post-practice stick-handling drills. O'Reilly spun and dangled defenders to take a shot on net, and then went and retrieved the puck on the forecheck so he could do it again.
When his second shot was kicked out, Rasmus Ristolainen took what Sabres coach Dan Bylsma called his "patented move," driving wide and cutting across the net-frontlike he was in the World Junior Championship all over again. But his shot was stopped too, and his attempt on a rebound went off the post.
"It's on us," O'Reilly said. "Even the first, it doesn't matter, I think, possession, whether it's hits faceoffs and shots … It's putting the puck in the net. I myself have to find a way to do that early and provide life because you just see it too many times, we fall into that and we know it's 'OK, we can't get scored on or it's gonna be a tough way to come back."
On one hand, the Sabres can look at this game and come away knowing they outshot and out chanced the Red Wings, and that they likely would've won had won more puck missed the post. On the other hand, they admitted that pulling their record to .500 was a goal of theirs - a win would've given them 20 points in 20 games - and they came up short of that goal by missing their opportunities.
"You kind of feel that a number of times," Bylsma said. "Obviously tonight's game we're right there, we're leaving a point on the table with just not burying that chance, not getting that goal right there at the end in overtime. You can look at the shootout loss against Ottawa and the overtime against New Jersey and those would add three wins in the column and that would be a huge difference for us."
The Sabres next chance to get to .500 will come Friday, when they play on the road against the Washington Capitals.