But after the Stars won a 4-2 game at Enterprise Center in Game 5 and had a chance to close out the series in Game 6 in Dallas Sunday, the odds were looking good for a potential third round. So you could see this as a lost opportunity.
The Blues marched into American Airlines Center and imposed their will in a 4-1 victory in Game 6. They then did the same thing while dominating the second and third periods Tuesday. Through that 40-minute span, the Stars were outshot 31-3 and deserved pretty much all of that imbalance.
St. Louis' plan all series has been to establish its cycle, keep the puck in the offensive zone and wear down the Stars' small defense. They also have wanted to get into Ben Bishop's kitchen, and create all sorts of problems for the big goalie.
They did that, and then some.
The Blues hemmed the Stars in their own end for so long that when Dallas could get the puck out, the players were exhausted and couldn't muster the energy to create a counter-attack.
"They were coming, and we didn't find a way to adjust," center Tyler Seguin said. "We just didn't do anything and didn't grab the momentum. They're a good hockey team. I thought in overtime we started going a bit more, started getting more speed and zone time down there, but obviously not enough."
During that time, Bishop kept them in it. The big goalie, who calls St. Louis home, stood tall through shot after shot and kept the score 1-1. The bar-down goal he did allow may have been tipped, and then he was a wall after that.
He stood his ground against physical play, he sealed his posts, he ventured out of the net to help his struggling teammates handle the puck. He was Superman.
"He's just a great competitor and a great goaltender," Montgomery said. "He's up for the Vezina Trophy for a reason. He's an extremely talented goaltender and he manages the game really well."