What's old was new again in the opening minute as it took former CBJ defenseman David Savard just 15 seconds to put a shot on net that was stopped by Merzlikins. The CBJ goalie also made stops on Barclay Goodrow and Brayden Point in the opening minutes before having some free time late in the period, as the Lightning didn't get a shot on goal in the last 11:34 of the frame.
That allowed Columbus to take a 1-0 lead when given a power play near the midway point of the frame. Patrik Laine protected the puck and got it Bjorkstrand, who teed up Jones at the top of the zone for a slap shot that deflected off the stick of Alex Killorn and past goalie Curtis McElhinney at the 9:36 mark.
The Blue Jackets had a chance to double the lead early in the second period as Bjorkstrand sprung Jack Roslovic on a breakawway, but McElhinney made the save with his blocker to deny the CBJ center.
Merzlikins made a fantastic stop with Tampa Bay on the power play as he stuck out his right pad to deny a deflection at the top of the crease by Alex Killorn, but the Bolts would tie the score with 5:09 left in the frame. A CBJ turnover in the neutral zone was gathered by Yanni Gourde, who threw a pass across the zone to Coleman for a slap shot from the right circle that went off Merzlikins glove and bounced across the line to make it a 1-1 game.
Merzlikins made a big stop on Killorn early in the third period, but Tampa Bay kept pushing and took a 2-1 lead at 8:14 of the period. Merzlikins stopped a shot by Erik Cernak from a sharp angle, but Killorn tracked down the rebound and centered from south of the red line to the onrushing Ondrej Palat, who beat the CBJ goalie far side from the right circle to give the Lightning its first lead.
Columbus pulled Merzlikins for an extra attacker with more than 2:30 to go, but Laine unfortunately fanned on a shot and Coleman threw the puck 170 feet down the ice for an empty-net goal with 24.8 seconds left to set the final score.