Buffalo pulled even on a rush goal of its own in the back half of the first. Jeff Skinner carried from then half-wall in his own end into Washington territory. His pass to Tage Thompson caromed off the big pivot's skates and came right back to Skinner, who shoveled a backhander from the slot that eluded Samsonov on the stick side, tying the game at 1-1 at 15:49 of the first.
Washington regained the lead early in the second, doing so less than a minute after Samsonov denied Skinner's breakaway bid. The Caps put some heat on the Sabres in their own end, and with some chaos down low and in front, Conor Sheary passed to Dmitry Orlov at the left point. Orlov's shot missed, ccaroming off the glass to Jensen on the right side. Jensen crept up to the top of the right circle before firing a shot through traffic and past Tokarski's glove hand on the short side at 4:06 of the second.
"I saw all their guys collapse because our guys got to the net and caused chaos that forced their wingers and the guys that cover the [defensemen] to collapse down," recounts Jensen. "They were trying to block it, and I saw we had a guy in front. So I just found a lane, and I shot it."
The Caps let loose of the lead when Buffalo scored twice in a span of less than three minutes in the middle of the middle period, doing so with a pair of sustained shifts in the Washington zone. Skinner's second of the night tied it up at 10:23; he fired through Samsonov's five-hole from the right circle after the Caps couldn't clear the zone. At the time of Skinner's second goal, four of the five Washington skaters had been on the ice for a minute and 42 seconds.
At 12:55, Victor Olofsson finished off another lengthy offensive-zone shift for Buffalo, converting a Casey Mittelstadt pass down low to make it 3-2. At the time of that tally, both Caps defensemen had been on the ice for two minutes. Laviolette used his timeout at that juncture, and the Caps settled down soon after.
"They scored two goals, and the two or three shifts prior to that weren't good," says Laviolette. "It was almost like as soon as we went out, we stopped playing. And it was good; the guys responded from that point. We didn't let up very much after that defensively and got back on the attack offensively."
With just under four minutes left in the second, the Caps pulled even on Ovechkin's 41st goal of the season. Evgeny Kuznetsov won a right dot draw, pulling the puck to Ovechkin in the pocket. The Caps' captain instantly cranked a shot past Tokarski, high to the stick side, tying the game at 3-3 at 16:47 of the third. Only a single second of game time elapsed between the puck drop and the red light.