Late in the period, Holtby bolted from his crease and skated out almost to the blueline in an attempt to beat an onrushing Ristolainen to a loose puck high in Washington ice. He did, but he put it right on Sheary's stick in the process. With the net empty and the Sabres in possession, and with a desperate second effort, Holtby was able to pokecheck the puck off Sheary's stick and into the seats, gaining a timely stoppage for Washington.
The Caps maintained that 1-0 lead into the third while continuing to press unsuccessfully for more offense. Buffalo was doing the same, and the two sides went back and forth, often missing the net on both sides, but both goaltenders were on top of their respective games as well.
The Sabres' fourth line evened the game up on a strong offensive zone shift just ahead of the midpoint of the third. Holtby made the stop on Tage Thompson's shot, but the rebound went directly to Johan Larsson, and he buried it before the Caps netminder could reset, making it a 1-1 game at 9:01.