The Minnesota Wild center received one fifth-place vote, good for one point, tying him for 17th place with Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby, Boston Bruins center Patrice Bergeron and Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Victor Hedman, who won the Norris Trophy.
It was good company, but Staal had them beat in one area.
RELATED: [McDavid edges Crosby as early favorite for Hart Trophy]
He scored 42 goals, fourth in the NHL behind Washington Capitals left wing Alex Ovechkin (49), Winnipeg Jets right wing Patrik Laine (44) and Vegas Golden Knights center William Karlsson (43).
"I needed to score a few more goals, I guess," Staal said, laughing.
Said Wild teammate Jason Zucker, "I have no doubt he can do it again."
Staal, who turns 34 on Oct. 29, is confident too, even if he won't guarantee he'll score 42 goals again.
"I think I can still produce and I feel like I can still be a top point producer and goal scorer for our team," he said.
Staal has been the Wild's leading scorer and arguably the best bargain in the NHL since signing his three-year, $10.5 million contract ($3.5 million average annual value) on July 1, 2016.
He has 141 points (70 goals, 71 assists) in 166 games with the Wild, including two this season.
It's been a career resurgence in Minnesota for Staal, who had 154 points (57 goals, 97 assists) in 239 games with the Carolina Hurricanes and New York Rangers in three seasons prior to arriving in Minnesota.
He's also coming off his first season at least 40 goals since scoring 40 with the Hurricanes in 2008-09.
Staal, who is five goals shy of 400 in the NHL, cites confidence and opportunity as the biggest reasons for his turnaround.
"In order to continue to play and play at a high level, you have to expect more out of yourself, because if you don't you'll be left to the side pretty quickly," Staal said. "I've had moments where confidence wasn't very high as well, but you have to have an inner belief inside you to get back to that level. That's where I was at the end of my time with the Rangers. I knew inside what I could do, it was just about finding the right situation and spot. Fortunately it's been great [in Minnesota], but you have to do that every year and prove that every year."
He thinks he can. He's confident he will. So are the Wild.
Minnesota next plays the Chicago Blackhawks at Xcel Energy Center on Thursday (8 p.m. ET; FS-N, FS-WI, WGN, NHL.TV).
"He looks like the same person to me," Wild coach Bruce Boudreau said prior to the season. "He doesn't look like he's gotten slower. He doesn't look like he's aged. He has the same enthusiasm.