Gallant did not deserve to be fired based on performance. He received a two-year contract extension Jan. 2 and guided the Panthers to the most wins (47) and points (103) in their history last season. He got them to the Stanley Cup Playoffs for the first time in four years and was a finalist for the Jack Adams Award as NHL coach of the year.
The Panthers lost to the New York Islanders in six games in the Eastern Conference First Round but outplayed the Islanders for much of the series.
They're 11-10-1 this season, two points out of a playoff spot, in better shape than they were at this point last season, even though the front office overhauled the defense in the offseason and the roster has been hampered by injuries. Three top-nine forwards have missed significant time: Jonathan Huberdeau (all 22 games), Nick Bjustad (19) and Jussi Jokinen (10).
"I'm disappointed for him," said Blackhawks defenseman Brian Campbell, who spent the past five seasons with the Panthers. "I feel bad for him. I don't know. They're above .500. No team's where they want to be, but he's done some good things there. I know the guys liked him. So it's kind of shocking."
But this decision wasn't based on whether Gallant deserved it. Other than inconsistency early this season, it was based on how Gallant fit into the bigger picture.
Gallant was hired by Tallon when Tallon was GM, and Rowe became GM after last season. Eric Joyce and Steve Werier rose from within to become assistant GMs.
The Panthers have placed an emphasis on analytics. Rowe said it was part of their process, not all of it, and Gallant wasn't totally against it. But there was more to it.
"There was definitely a philosophical divide, you could call it," Rowe said. "We wanted to develop a team and build a team that was fast, could move the puck quickly, attack the offensive net, pressure the puck in all three zones. Gerard and I talked about it, and he said he wanted to get a little more size, and we decided to go in a different direction. Were we on the same page every day of the week? No, when it came to that."
That is enough to make a change, for the sake of Gallant as well as the Panthers, and perhaps it wasn't clear until recently, based on the timing of the move. Gallant deserves to be in a situation in which he fits and no doubt will find one elsewhere; the Panthers need everyone on the same page every day of the week.
"I think you've got to let guys go out there and do their jobs a little bit," Campbell said. "And if that's the case, then it's kind of tough to do your job when that's what they hired you for and you're kind of not doing it."