Talbot, who entered the night a rookie in that department, also, knew he was swimming upstream when he skated out and sized up his opponent. But he has no regrets.
"I've seen (Smith). He's a big boy, so I knew it wasn't really going to work out well for me," Talbot said. "But at the same time, it was one of those things that felt like the right thing to do in that moment.
"I got a couple messages from guys on their team and they said he respected me for meeting him out there. I respected him for doing the same."
In that moment, Talbot's razor-thin patience had officially run dry with his old 'mates.
The temp of the trickling venom finally rose to an all-out boil.
He'd just made his 19th save of the period, sprawled out and covered the loose puck with a snow-angel to prevent a 6-3 score from scarring any further. Sam Gagner - convinced it was loose (it wasn't) - then dove into the blue paint and speared the helpless netminder under the arm in a painful effort to score.
Enough was enough.
Talbot leapt to his knees and began feeding his former teammate with the business end of his blocker hand, over and over.
Within seconds, Alex Chiasson got involved, but the netminder broke free from a headlock, turned to face the perpetrator, and delivered a bevy of blows with his clenched right fist.
Talbot was irate; incensed. Nothing was going right on the scoreboard, and he wasn't about to be taken advantage of.
The situation appeared over, but Talbot - still seething - caught wind of his padded counterpart standing at centre and soon, without pause, the offer was accepted.
"I actually didn't see him standing there until Darnell (Nurse) was like, 'Go. He's right there - go!' I was like, 'Thanks for that, buddy.' I think they knew how it was going to work out for me, too," he joked.
Irrelevant.
He showed heart. To stand up, skate over and accept the challenge in the first place tells you everything you need to know about Talbot's character.
Oh, did the crowd roar.
And backstage, his phone was blowing up
"They didn't tell me I wasn't going back in until the refs settled it with about five minutes left in the intermission," Talbot said. "By the time I got my gear off, I had about 45 messages already. People back home, people from here - it was pretty crazy the reaction it got."
As fun as it was for those on the stands and even the press box, Talbot doesn't expect a repeat performance anytime soon.
But he also knows what a moment like that can do to galvanize a team.
"Everyone's got each other's back," Talbot said.